My problem is that the NCAA punishes the wrong people, and in the wrong ways. No one cares that UMass' and Memphis' Final Fours were stricken from the records -- they still got to enjoy them.
If, say, Memphis got to enjoy the fruits of an ineligible player for an entire season, then take away their next season in some form or another. Be it scholarships, postseason ban, or even a 1-year death penalty.