As the end of the regular season is but a week away, this topic is appropriate, so here goes:
POY: McDermott
ROY: Garrett (over Jordan)
COY: McDermott (he and Wright are in the 10 finalists for national COY)
First Team:
Cotton
Christon
Starks
Pinkston
Bell
Second Team:
DSR
Dunham
Gardner
Edwin
Marshall
Third Team:
Harrison
Young
Sampson
Wragge
Stainbrook
Honorable Mention (mostly to list candidates considered for the above teams): Arcidiacono, Woods, Batts, Henton, Teague
A few comments/reasons:
The G'town guards are that high because of the load they have to take on every night, and they have done it well, but I did waffle on DVR between 2nd and 3rd team. I think Edwin is underrated by many, who do not consider his very high steals in addition to scoring. Gardner over Stainbrook because he is their #1 offensive player, whereas Stainbrook has Semaj. Harrison is overrated - high volume shooter, low %, does not make his teammates better. Wragge is a one-trick pony but an important pony for that team's style and he opens room for McDermott to operate. Sampson was considered for 2nd team (instead of Dunham or DVR) but by relying so heavily on the mid-range game he has not reached the potential (even as a soph) that he has. It would not take much to convince me to put Arcidiacono on the 3rd team -- he makes his teammates better and runs a tight ship.
Fire away.